Why the Kimberley process is flawed?
The process has two main flaws. First, its narrow terms of certification focus solely on the mining and distribution of conflict diamonds, meaning that broader issues around worker exploitation – the health and safety of working conditions, the use of child labour and fair pay – are not addressed.
What are some of the issues associated with the production and sales of conflict diamonds?
Environment. Due to poor planning and weak regulation, diamond mining has caused environmental devastation, severely damaging the land and water. This irresponsible mining has caused soil erosion and deforestation, and has forced local communities to relocate.
Why diamond rings are unethical?
While diamonds have long been associated with some of the happiest days of one’s life, they can also be the source of so much suffering for others. From human rights abuses and blood diamonds to habitat destruction and water pollution, the truth is that diamond mining is a messy business.
What are the ethical issues in the movie Blood Diamond?
The main ethical issue is the violence. The violence is can be ethical issue because no one have a rights to use violence for any matters include the government itself.
What is a limitation of the Kimberley Process?
Its limitations: It has a narrow definition of conflict diamonds: Conflict diamonds are defined by the Kimberley Process as ‘rough diamonds used by rebel movements to finance wars against legitimate governments’.
Can you trust the Kimberley Process?
Although there can never be a cast-iron guarantee about the provenance of diamonds, Mr Blom of the World Federation of Diamond Bourses believes the public can rest assured that the Kimberley Process is a robust system that works most of the time.
What are the negative effects of diamond mining?
Diamond mining also has many detrimental impacts on the environment including soil erosion, deforestation, and ecosystem destruction. A major political effect of the diamond commodity chain, specifically at the mining level is blood diamonds. These are diamonds that are produced in war zones to finance civil wars.
What are the negative effects of diamond mining in South Africa?
An indirect effect of mining is the larger population increases strains in the water supplies and have led to an increase of pollution in rivers. On average the pollution in rivers due to acid drainage by diamond mines has increased by 36% between 1956 and 2003.
Do blood diamonds still exist 2019?
It shows that the production of conflict diamonds still exists in Sierra Leone. According to the 2005 Country Reports on Human Right Practices of Africa from the United States, serious human rights issues still exist in Sierra Leone, even though the 11-year civil conflict had officially ended by 2002.
Are Tiffany diamonds blood diamonds?
Many people believe the Tiffany diamond is a “blood diamond”. On its website, Tiffany & Co states that all of its diamonds are “conflict-free”. It said it has taken “rigorous steps” to ensure that conflict diamonds do not enter its inventory.
Is Blood Diamond historically accurate?
The diamond industry is abuzz over the new film Blood Diamond, a fictional account of rebel militias in Sierra Leone fueling a bloody civil war through the sale of the precious gems. He promises to help a poor black fisherman find his kidnapped son in exchange for help locating the gemstone.
What are the human rights issues in Blood Diamond?
Violence. Even though many brutal civil wars have now ended, violence in diamond mines remains a serious problem. Many diamonds are still stained by severe human rights abuses such as forced labor, beatings, torture, and murder.
What is Kimberley Process Certification?
Kimberley Diamonds Process Certification. The Clean Diamond Trade Act was signed into law on July 29, 2003 which prohibits the “importation into, or exportation from, the U.S. of any rough diamond, from whatever source, unless the rough diamond has been controlled through the Kimberley Process Certification Scheme (KPCS)”.
What is the Russian Federation and the Kimberley Process?
The Russian Federation and the Kimberley Process. What is the. Kimberley Process? The Kimberley Process (KP) unites administrations, civil societies, and industry in reducing the flow of conflict diamonds – ‘rough diamonds used to finance wars against governments’ – around the world. See the process.
Does the Kimberley Process Work for Human Rights?
Organisations such as Human Rights Watch have also argued that the Kimberley Process is too narrow in scope and does not adequately serve to eliminate other human rights concerns from the diamond production chain. A man and two children sifting for diamonds in Sierra Leone.
Who are the Kimberley Process participants in rough diamonds?
The Kimberley Process (KP) participants are states and regional economic integration organizations that are eligible to trade in rough diamonds. As from November 2018, there are 55 participants representing 82 countries, with the European Community counting as a single participant.